A penalty provision in the marital settlement agreement


by Jeralyn Lawrence, Family Law Attorney, Lawrence Law

In New Jersey divorces, marital settlement agreements include language that addresses the ramifications if either person breaches any provision of the agreement. Often, the agreement includes a penalty provision that requires breaching party to pay the other’s counsel fees if the matter requires court intervention. More often than not, courts have largely ignored such penalty provisions. By not enforcing this provision, it lost its power and deterrence of breaches.

However, a recent New Jersey appellate division case, Holtham, Jr. v. Lucas, was upheld and the penalty provision was enforced. Previously, the trial court assessed an $18,450 sanction against the husband. This figure represented $150 per day for each and every day he remained in violation of the agreement.

The court placed a significant amount of weight on the public policy of enforcing agreements. As such, it considered this bargained for penalty provision necessary ensure peace for both parties post-divorce. Because it was a vital piece of the agreement, it warranted its enforcement.

The court held that the parties entered into the agreement with relative bargaining power. Similarly, the parties also had sufficient sophistication and understanding of the provision. And, both had the benefit of counsel.

In conclusion, this is an important case. It empowers courts to properly sanction those who willfully and wrongfully violate bargained for terms of an agreement.

For more information about this blog or other divorce, matrimonial or family law issues contact me at moc.m1571489535rifwa1571489535lwal@1571489535ecner1571489535walj1571489535.


Jeralyn Lawrence is a family law attorney with Lawrence Law in Watchung. She also serves as Second Vice President of the New Jersey State Bar Association (slated to become President in 2022), is the Past Chair of the Family Law Section of the NJSBA, and serves as Second Vice-President of the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers. She can be reached at moc.m1571489535rifwa1571489535lwal@1571489535ecner1571489535walj1571489535 or (908) 645-1000.

This is a sponsored section. The advisors have paid a fee to post their commentary here. Their sponsorship doesn’t influence any editorial decisions we make at NJMoneyHelp.com, or give them more or less exposure in our stories. Their posting does not constitute an endorsement by NJMoneyHelp.com.

Tags: